An international institution for Independent Neutral Evaluation

HomeServicesEarly Neutral Evaluation

TN/SVC/A10
Scoped pilot · by written quotation

Early Neutral Evaluation

Understand the merits before a dispute escalates.

Early Neutral Evaluation is a structured assessment of a defined dispute by an independent practitioner. It is normally non-binding and helps parties understand the merits, evidential gaps and practical litigation or settlement risks without requiring them to surrender their right to pursue formal proceedings.

A10 · Scoped pilot · by written quotation

At a glance.

(Eight answers)

The problem

A contested factual, contractual or technical question is threatening a relationship or heading towards proceedings, and each side is sure it is right.

Appropriate use

Two or more parties, or their counsel, who agree to a joint, non-binding evaluation of defined questions. Available in person or remotely (B06).
Not for: a single party acting alone (use Decision Review), a binding answer (Expert Determination) or settlement guarantees.

The result

A reasoned, non-binding report: the issues, competing explanations, the evidence basis, findings, uncertainty and limits.

The sequence

Identify the parties and authority → Agree the joint protocol → Independent conflict clearance → Scope and quote → Signature and payment → Submissions, evaluation and report

Pricing

Typically US$7,500 – 25,000 in total, usually shared equally, confirmed by written quote. Fees never depend on the outcome.

How long

Typically 4–8 weeks after submissions close, fixed in the procedural charter.

Independence

Jointly commissioned (Protocol B): all parties agree the scope, the neutral, the submissions and who receives the report. It is never applied to a one-sided review.

Action

Request a scope review
Every party must agree before the evaluation starts; a request does not create an engagement.

§ 01When to use it

Who it is for.

Two or more disputing parties, their counsel and referring institutions.

  • Commercial contract and payment disputes
  • Shareholder, joint-venture and supply-chain disagreements
  • Construction delay, variation or defects disputes
  • Parties preparing for mediation, arbitration or court proceedings

§ 02What you receive

The deliverable.

  • Jointly agreed evaluation terms and confidentiality/admissibility position
  • Equal opportunity to present positions and respond
  • Evaluation meeting if appropriate
  • Written merits assessment stating issues, evidence, material gaps, reasoning, scenarios and non-binding view

§ 03How it works

5 steps.

01

One party starts request and identifies the other party or counsel

02

Invite each participant

Require consent or a valid referral basis.

03

Conflicts and legal seat/procedural rules checked

Evaluator shortlist or appointment.

04

Both sides accept scope and payment split

Pay as agreed.

05

Exchange submissions on a controlled timetable

Evaluator hears both sides; report delivered under joint mandate.

§ 04Fees, payment and delivery

What it costs, when you pay, what you receive.

(Terms)

Fee basis

Typically US$7,500 – 25,000 in total, set by the complexity of the dispute and the number of parties, usually shared equally, and confirmed in a written quote. Fees never depend on the outcome.

When you pay

A deposit is requested only after every party has authorised the process and conflicts are cleared. How the fee is split, and what happens if a party does not pay, is written into the agreement.

Delivery

A fixed schedule on your dashboard; the written evaluation is delivered to all parties at the same time under the agreed protocol. Mediation can follow under a separate agreement.

§ 05Important limits

What it is not.

(Limits)

Read before you commission

An Early Neutral Evaluation is not binding unless separately and lawfully constituted, does not ensure settlement and does not override court or arbitral procedural orders.

Independence

Every engagement is subject to suitability review and conflict clearance before any fee is taken. Fees are never linked to the outcome.

§ 06Next

Related services.