An international institution for Independent Neutral Evaluation

HomeNeutral EvaluationExamples

TN/EVL/EX
Illustrative · Edition 2027

What an evaluation produces

Three evaluations, shown from question to report.

These examples show the process, the deliverable and its limits. They are illustrative: the parties, facts and figures are fictional, and none describes a completed matter. Real case summaries appear here only when clients consent to publication, and are anonymised.

§ 01Example 1 · Construction

A disputed variation and delay on a hospital project.

A contractor claims 64 days’ extension and the cost of an instructed change to the building services; the employer accepts 20 days and disputes the cost. Both want to avoid arbitration while the project is still live.

Illustrative example · fictional parties, facts and figures · not a completed matter

(Mandate)

The question as framed

Is the contractor entitled to an extension of time for the change to the building services, and if so for how many days, on the contract and the records supplied?

Protocol

Early Neutral Evaluation, jointly commissioned; equal written submissions and one evaluation meeting; non-binding; costs shared equally.

Material reviewed

The contract’s variation and extension clauses, the instruction, the programme updates, site diaries, both parties’ delay analyses.

Fee basis and timing

Quoted by complexity and parties; delivered on a fixed schedule agreed in the mandate.

How the report reads · headline conclusions

  • The instruction is a variation under the contract; entitlement in principle is established.
  • The records support a critical-path effect of 38 to 46 days; the 64-day claim relies on a programme revision not shown to have been accepted.
  • Cost is assessed separately and is not addressed in this evaluation.

Stated uncertainty

  • Two months of site diaries are missing; if produced, they could move the range in either direction.
  • Neither analysis accounts for a concurrent supplier delay; its effect is identified, not quantified.

What the evaluation did not decide

  • Whether the employer must pay the cost of the change.
  • Any finding of fault, and any question outside the defined mandate.

§ 02Example 2 · Shareholders

Two owners who cannot agree what the business is worth.

Two founders of a distribution company hold 50% each. One wants to exit under the shareholders’ agreement; they disagree on the valuation basis the agreement requires.

Illustrative example · fictional parties, facts and figures · not a completed matter

(Mandate)

The question as framed

Which valuation basis does the shareholders’ agreement require for a voluntary exit, and what range does that basis produce on the accounts supplied?

Protocol

Clarity DeepView, jointly commissioned by both shareholders; structured document review and one interview with each; non-binding.

Material reviewed

The shareholders’ agreement, three years of accounts, the current management accounts and each side’s valuation proposal.

Fee basis and timing

DeepView quoted after scope review with complexity and specialist work quoted; usually 7–12 working days, agreed on each scope.

How the report reads · headline conclusions

  • The agreement requires fair value without a minority discount; one proposal applies a discount the agreement does not permit.
  • On that basis the accounts support a range, with the main driver being the treatment of one customer contract due for renewal.
  • The owners can narrow the gap by agreeing how that contract is treated.

Stated uncertainty

  • Renewal of the main customer contract is uncertain; the report shows the range with and without it.
  • The management accounts are unaudited.

What the evaluation did not decide

  • The price either owner must pay or accept.
  • Any question of conduct between the shareholders.

§ 03Example 3 · Board decision

A board about to acquire one of its suppliers.

A manufacturer’s board is asked to approve the acquisition of a key supplier. The recommendation rests on cost savings presented by the deal team.

Illustrative example · fictional parties, facts and figures · not a completed matter

(Mandate)

The question as framed

Do the evidence and assumptions in the board paper support the stated cost savings, and which assumptions would change the recommendation if they proved wrong?

Protocol

Independent Decision Review, commissioned by the board’s audit committee; restricted report to named directors; explicit reliance limits.

Material reviewed

The board paper, the savings model, supplier performance data and the alternatives the paper considered.

Fee basis and timing

Independent Decision Review typically US$9,500 – 35,000; delivered as a restricted report with version history.

How the report reads · headline conclusions

  • About two thirds of the stated savings rest on documented price differences; the remainder relies on volume assumptions not yet tested.
  • The paper does not compare the acquisition with a long-term supply agreement, which would deliver part of the savings without integration risk.
  • Three assumptions carry the case; each is listed with the evidence that would confirm or weaken it.

Stated uncertainty

  • Integration cost is estimated by the deal team only.
  • Supplier data covers two years.

What the evaluation did not decide

  • Whether the board should approve the acquisition: the decision stays with the board.
  • Any valuation, audit or fairness opinion.

§ 04Reading these examples

What every evaluation shares.

(Shared features)

A bounded question

Each mandate defines one answerable question before any material is reviewed.

Visible reasoning

Conclusions are traceable to evidence, with the strength of each stated.

Stated uncertainty

What could change the view is set out, not hidden.

Clear limits

What the evaluation did not decide is written into the report.