An international institution for Independent Neutral Evaluation

HomeServicesIndependent Decision Review

TN/SVC/A09
Scoped pilot · by written quotation

Independent Decision Review

Scrutinise a major decision before commitment.

An Independent Decision Review tests the central assumptions of a proposed action through a disclosed, single-commissioner mandate. The evaluator reviews the available evidence, alternatives, sensitivity to changed facts and important unknowns. The result helps authorised decision-makers exercise their own judgement.

A09 · Scoped pilot · by written quotation

At a glance.

(Eight answers)

The problem

A board, investor or leadership team is about to commit on a paper that may be incomplete, optimistic or written by people with a stake in the answer.

Appropriate use

One consequential decision with an authorised commissioning entity: an acquisition, a major contract, a capital project or a strategic change.
Not for: deciding a third party’s rights, legal or regulatory advice, valuations or fairness opinions.

The result

A decision brief: assumptions tested, evidence gaps, credible alternatives, risk and uncertainty, and a reasoned independent view, with reliance limits.

The sequence

Choose the decision → Role and risk screen → Commissioner and terms → Reviewer conflict clearance → Quote, mandate and payment → Analysis, quality check, report

Pricing

Focused review US$9,500 – 15,000; full review with interviews or a specialist US$18,000 – 35,000; panels quoted. 50% on signature, 50% on delivery.

How long

Typically 2–6 weeks, fixed in the written scope.

Independence

Commissioned by one organisation (Protocol A). The review does not hear or bind absent parties and does not imply anyone else agreed to it.

Action

Request a Decision Review
We respond with a suitability decision and a scoped quote; a request does not create an engagement.

§ 01When to use it

Who it is for.

Boards, investment committees, private equity, family enterprises and senior executives.

  • A major strategic investment, acquisition or divestment
  • A conflicted or contested board paper
  • Pre-investment thesis or valuation assumption
  • Restructuring, succession or capital-allocation decisions

§ 02What you receive

The deliverable.

  • Decision question and approved terms of reference
  • Assumptions-and-evidence map
  • Independent review of alternatives, material risks and critical unknowns
  • Board-ready reasoned memorandum, with explicit limitations

§ 03How it works

5 steps.

01

Select decision review and state decision deadline without confidential detail

02

Declare decision sponsor, beneficiaries and potentially affected persons

03

Receive evaluator options, conflict statements and written information limits

04

Approve report format, milestone dates, quote and rights to publish or rely

05

Pay initial agreed invoice

Supply secured documents; receive report and optional board briefing.

Who commissions it

For the people who must approve a major decision.

One organisation can commission a review on its own: no counterparty needs to agree. The decision always stays with you.

What the report looks like

Two illustrative report excerpts.

Illustrative excerpt · fictional organisation and figures

Acquisition of a key supplier

A manufacturer’s board was asked to approve buying a supplier on the strength of projected cost savings.

Headline conclusions

  • About two thirds of the stated savings rest on documented price differences.
  • The remainder relies on volume assumptions not yet tested against demand forecasts.
  • A long-term supply agreement, not considered in the paper, would capture part of the savings at lower risk.

Stated uncertainty

  • Integration cost was estimated by the deal team only.
  • Supplier performance data covers two years.

What the review did not decide

  • Whether to approve the acquisition.
  • Any valuation, audit or fairness opinion.

Illustrative excerpt · fictional organisation and figures

Business case for a regional logistics hub

An investment committee was asked to fund a US$40m distribution hub justified by faster delivery and lower transport cost.

Headline conclusions

  • Transport savings are supported by current contracts and route data.
  • The revenue uplift from faster delivery is asserted, not evidenced, and carries most of the return.
  • Three of the five risks in the paper have no owner or mitigation.

Stated uncertainty

  • Fuel and labour cost forecasts beyond three years.
  • Customer response to faster delivery has not been tested.

What the review did not decide

  • Whether to fund the hub.
  • The choice of site or contractor.

Illustrative: the organisations, figures and findings are fictional. Every real report states its reliance limits and who may rely on it.

Fees and timing

Published ranges, confirmed by written quote.

ReviewTypical feeWhat it covers
Focused reviewUS$9,500 – 15,000One decision paper and its model; written findings in 2–3 weeks.
Full reviewUS$18,000 – 35,000Paper, model, interviews and one specialist; restricted report and board briefing in 3–6 weeks.
Panel reviewQuotedTwo or three evaluators for complex, multi-disciplinary or high-value decisions.

A 50% deposit on signature and the balance on delivery. Fees never depend on the recommendation. Terms of Engagement.

Proposal pack

What a board receives before it commissions.

  • The decision question as we would frame it, and what is outside scope.
  • The reviewer profile and the conflict-check result.
  • The material we would examine and the interviews we would hold.
  • Timetable, fixed fee and reliance terms: who may rely on the report and for what.
  • A sample report structure, so you know what the board will receive.

§ 04Fees, payment and delivery

What it costs, when you pay, what you receive.

(Terms)

Fee basis

Typically US$9,500 – 15,000 for a focused review of one decision paper and US$18,000 – 35,000 for a full review with interviews or a specialist, confirmed in a written quote after scope review. Fees never depend on the outcome.

When you pay

A scoped corporate quote with a deposit and milestones, invoiced to the commissioning organisation. Fees never depend on recommending any particular decision.

Delivery

A restricted report or board pack issued to nominated recipients, with an auditable version history.

§ 05Important limits

What it is not.

(Limits)

Read before you commission

A Decision Review is not a fairness opinion, audit opinion, investment recommendation, regulated valuation or legal approval, unless specifically commissioned from properly qualified providers.

Independence

Every engagement is subject to suitability review and conflict clearance before any fee is taken. Fees are never linked to the outcome.

§ 06Next

Related services.