What you receive
Inside a Neutral Evaluation report.
The report is the product. It states what was asked, what was examined, what it shows, how confident the evaluator is, and who may rely on it.
§ 01Mandatory content
Eight things every evaluation states.
The precise question
Framed and agreed in writing before any work begins.
Who asked, who pays, under what authority
The commissioner and the protocol are disclosed.
Independence and conflicts
What was disclosed and how an independent officer cleared it.
Material reviewed, and what was not
Every source, and what was unavailable.
Competing interpretations, tested
Each reading of the evidence examined, fact kept apart from inference.
A reasoned conclusion
Calibrated to the strength of the material.
Uncertainty
What remains open, and what would change the view.
Use and reliance limits
Who may rely on the report, and for what.
§ 02Variable depth
What changes between the levels.
§ 03Calibration
Confidence is visible in the sentence.
The material clearly supports it
The conclusion follows from evidence that is consistent and sufficient.
More likely than not
The weight of the evidence points one way, with stated gaps.
A provisional view
The material is thin or conflicting; the report says what would change the view.
§ 04Delivery
How the report reaches you.
A second professional checks
A separate reviewer checks evidence support, scope and confidentiality before anything is issued.
A locked, signed report
The final report is fingerprinted, released only to the people named in the mandate, and corrected only by a dated addendum.
A full specimen report is shown to members in the Neutral Evaluation Handbook (Annexure D).